Library guide · Governance
Private Trust Company vs Professional Trustee: Which Should a Family Use?
A trustee the family controls, or one it hires. How a private trust company differs from a professional trust company on control, cost, regulation and succession.
A private trust company (PTC) is a company created only to act as trustee of one family's trusts, with a board the family can shape; a professional trustee is a licensed trust company that serves many clients for a fee. A PTC gives the family more control, continuity and understanding of complex assets, at higher cost and with governance duties it must meet itself; a professional trustee is simpler and cheaper for smaller or conventional structures. In Jersey, the Cayman Islands and the BVI, a PTC is exempt from trust licensing if it serves only connected family trusts.
Key takeaways
- A PTC acts as trustee only for one family's connected trusts and does not offer services to the public.
- The family can shape the PTC board, usually mixing family members, trusted advisers and independent professionals.
- Jersey, the Cayman Islands and the BVI exempt qualifying PTCs from trust licensing; Jersey requires administration by a licensed local provider.
- The PTC is commonly owned by a purpose trust or foundation, not by a family member, to avoid probate and tax problems.
Every trust needs a trustee, the person or company that legally holds the assets and must act for the beneficiaries. Most families hire a professional trust company. Some create their own trustee instead: a private trust company. The choice decides who makes the decisions about the family's wealth for decades.
| Question | Private trust company | Professional trustee |
|---|---|---|
| Who it serves | One family's connected trusts only | Many unrelated clients |
| Who decides | A board the family can shape | The trust company's own officers and policies |
| Complex or concentrated assets | Can hold them if the board accepts the risk | Often reluctant, or charges more |
| Regulation | Exempt from trust licensing if conditions are met (Jersey, Cayman, BVI) | Fully licensed and supervised |
| Cost | Higher: board, administration, audit | Lower for simple structures: a fee |
| Continuity | Stays with the family across generations | Staff and policies change; the trustee can be replaced |
| Governance burden | On the family and the board | On the professional trustee |
What a private trust company is
A private trust company is a company whose only purpose is to act as trustee of a specific trust or a group of connected trusts, usually for one family. It does not offer trustee services to the public and does not run a commercial trust business. The family can shape its board, typically combining family members, trusted advisers and independent professionals, so decisions stay aligned with the family's intentions without the trustee becoming a personal extension of the settlor. For the basics, see What Is a Private Trust Company?
How the leading jurisdictions treat it
Trust business is normally a licensed activity. The leading trust jurisdictions exempt qualifying PTCs:
- Cayman Islands: a PTC registered under the Private Trust Companies Regulations (2020 Revision, amended in 2024) is exempt from licensing if it conducts only connected trust business, meaning trusts whose contributors are connected persons (Collas Crill).
- British Virgin Islands: the Financial Services (Exemptions) Regulations 2007 exempt a qualifying PTC from the trust licence normally required under the Banks and Trust Companies Act (Mourant). BVI PTCs are often combined with VISTA trusts when the family holds an operating business.
- Jersey: PTCs are exempt from licensing under the Financial Services (Jersey) Law 1998 if they meet specific conditions, including administration by a licensed Jersey trust company provider, which adds cost but also regulatory substance (Collas Crill, Walkers).
Why families choose a PTC
The strongest reasons are practical. A professional trustee may be reluctant to hold a concentrated or risky asset, such as a controlling stake in the family company, or will charge heavily to do so. A PTC board that understands the business can hold it. A PTC also offers continuity: the trustee does not change when a trust company is sold or its staff move on. And it keeps decisions inside a governance structure the family designed.
Why many families should not
A PTC is not free control. It needs a properly constituted board, minutes, administration and often an audit, which make it more expensive than a professional trustee for a conventional structure. The board carries fiduciary duties, and a board that simply follows the settlor's wishes can expose the trust to challenge, the classic "sham" risk. Ownership must be planned too: practitioners generally recommend a purpose trust or foundation as owner, because a PTC owned directly by a family member can require probate on death and can create tax exposure (Collas Crill).
How to choose
A professional trustee is usually right for modest or conventional trusts: portfolios of listed assets, a family home, standard succession. A private trust company becomes worth its cost when the trust holds large, complex or concentrated assets, when the family wants a lasting voice in trustee decisions, and when it is prepared to govern the PTC seriously. See Choosing and Running a Trust.
Frequently asked questions
- What is the difference between a private trust company and a professional trustee?
- A private trust company is set up only to act as trustee for one family's trusts, and the family can influence who sits on its board. A professional trustee is a licensed trust company that acts for many unrelated clients and applies its own policies. The PTC offers control and continuity; the professional trustee offers simplicity and an established compliance framework.
- Is a private trust company regulated?
- It depends on the jurisdiction. In the Cayman Islands, a PTC registered under the Private Trust Companies Regulations is exempt from licensing if it conducts only connected trust business. In the BVI, the Financial Services (Exemptions) Regulations 2007 exempt qualifying PTCs from the trust licence. In Jersey, PTCs are exempt from licensing under the Financial Services (Jersey) Law 1998, provided a licensed Jersey provider administers them.
- Who owns a private trust company?
- Usually a non charitable purpose trust or a foundation. Direct ownership by a family member is possible but can create problems: if the owner dies, probate may be needed and the PTC's operations may be disrupted, and direct ownership can create tax exposure in some countries.
- When does a private trust company make sense?
- When the trust holds large, complex or concentrated assets, such as an operating family business, that a professional trustee may be reluctant to hold or manage; when the family wants a lasting say in trustee decisions; and when the structure is large enough to justify the cost of a board, administration and audit.
This guide is educational and general in nature. It does not constitute investment, legal, tax or financial advice.
The letter
One thoughtful email.
Essays, frameworks and observations on family offices, capital allocation, governance and long-term wealth. Published when there is something worth reading.
No market noise. No investment tips. No daily emails.